Keep Me Logged In
I Forgot My Password!
Hi there, to get started:
I have been watching this Fallujah business fairly intently over the past few days and this is another example of failing to perceive the nature of the conflict. The news and the military are speaking of the insurgent effort fighting a last ditch effort in Fallujah. This is only partially true. I believe that the military will discover shortly that there was nowhere close to the 3000 militants in Fallujah that they projected. It will be no more than a few hundred. The various terrorist organizations have arranged for a small portion of fighters to make a symbolic last stand in Fallujah. The majority of these groups have already departed the city to find new havens throughout Iraq or beyond her borders. From those martyred in Fallujah perhaps three times that number will spring up elsewhere, inspired by the valiant fatalistic stand against hopeless odds. Islam, like most religions, is very susceptible to fatalism. What I think is more interesting is the developing attitudes on both sides. On the eve of the assault the residents and militants within Fallujah were heard chanting “God is great” amid the artillery strikes and aerial bombing. This is not surprising, of course. On the outside of the cordon similar activity was taking place. A Marine commander exhorted his troops saying, “The enemy has got a face. He’s called Satan. He lives in Falluja. And we’re going to destroy him.” (
News) Though this is but anecdote, I think it demonstrates an important point. The U.S. is in an ideological fight. If the political authorities refuse to color it that way, the soldiers themselves will. Ideology breeds ideology and asymmetrical warfare is always a temporary condition.
Add a Comment (3)
Thread parent sort order:
Minimize Replies to Comments
RE: fallujah fight
>What I think is more interesting is the developing attitudes on both sides. … Ideology breeds ideology and asymmetrical warfare is always a temporary condition. True, but do you think the ideology that’s shown by American ground forces will ever spread to the American public? In one of the email groups I’m in a person was saying that he couldn’t understand how we’d just attack the "innocent civilians of Fallujah." It seems to me that in general, there is a disconnect between your average American’s view of this war, and what’s really going on over there. Given that, I don’t know if idealogy is going anywhere but on the front lines. Thoughts?
Posted 11 October 2004,
This comment thread has
What is OmniNerd?
OmniNerd's content is generated by nerds like you.
Dzhokar Tsarnaev deserves due process?
Of course, he's an American on US soil.
Yes but ... damn.
Not when you're a menace to society like that.
No, he's a terrorist and the GWOT still stands.
35 votes, 4 comments
Top of This Page
Meta & Tools
Report a Bug
Contact & Socialize
© OmniNerd LLC 2013
— Content created and posted by OmniNerd users is provided under the
Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 US license.
OMNINERD, OmniNerd graphics, logos, designs, page headers, button icons, scripts, and other service names are the
of OmniNerd LLC