Then what about democracy?
As Mark has said, great article Will. I agree also that much of the history of Islam and the entire Muslim culture is clouded with a smoke screen and given a hand wave thoughout many educational levels. However, as I read this article I began to think about the creation of democracy, though a much newer form of government and as you know, run under the belief that church and state are seperated. Though not started in totally violent/war like manner like Islam (which as we all know is deeply embedded in the political views of many states), democracy, and those that live in democratic states, has continually forced its will, opinions, and theology on others by use of force and war much like the Islamic states of old and possibly the present have and do. With democracy being as "young" as it is, there is still a long history to be written before it collapses. Now to my point. Though there are huge fundamental differences between the theologies and basis for Islamic and democratic states, do you believe that at some point in history the democratic society could possibly be viewed much like we view the Islamic states today? If we take a look back at history, there are examples, I admit not exact mirrors of democracy, but none the less similar, where democracy was created in similar fashion as the Islamic states of today and has attempted to concur others and force the idea that democracy is the ONLY way to conduct business. How do you feel (if you do at all) that comparisons between the forcefullness of the Islamic states’ theologies differs from that of the means by which democratic states "push" their ideologies to other non-democratic states?
And finally, damnit Mark. I could sit on this site and respond to comments all day. Though not as well read as Will, many of the articles posted have some great debatable qualities. Look forward to visiting often! Maybe we’ll have to get together again, drink some beers and have some deep conversations about some of the presented topics. I’ll be sure to keep Erin away because she always wins!


Islam > democracy by willwaddell