RE: Disappearing Options
Its all out there now and it won’t go away however much you mock its existence.
I don’t think Brandon is saying that the things listed in that link don’t exist, only that this idea of the LDS church being very police-state like is inaccurate. When I read your posts, I get the image of big-brother-esque reporting and punishment. And it isn’t like that. Well, maybe except at BYU, but that is a whole different and creepy world. One which Brandon and I, as former students of Texas A&M, aren’t well versed in.
Typical members just don’t have to deal with this except under situations where they bring their problems to their congregational leader/bishop. So my and Brandon’s experience does not in any way jive with your understanding of it. That’s all. Not to say unnecessarily overreaches never happen, but the high irregular instances that you read about are drowned out in the multitude of interactions that are the norm. I’m pretty sure that is why he is mocking your term “LDS Discipline”.


RE: Disappearing Options by Occams
Thanks, that is reasonable and helps. I only pushed that discipline point because Brandon tried to dismiss it as amusing and histerical.
I can well accept that LDS has a pastoral interest in its followers that causes it to attempt to intervene if they appear to be losing the faith, or attacking their church, but which is not intrusive in other matters, and not at all like the pressure exerted in the more cult-like sects. Sadly, he did confirm my understanding that families may be damaged by church discipline regarding association with those who leave. Therefore there will always be some very hurt people around who are willing to talk to the kind of media who, in order to damage a President, will be happy paint it as a typical religious cult.
I can imagine what it must be like at BYU, and how that would not appeal to a couple of techo Aggies. I don’t doubt that a person could get an excellent education there in many subjects, but the idea of any religion dominating university life repels me too. That is the time of life when one should be exploring and experimenting with new ideas and not be dealing with academics who believe that they have all the answers. To be fair, it might be just as bad at a Baptist or Jesuit school as at one run by the LDS.