I have to agree with Occams, here. This is continental philosophy at its silliest.
The money symbol has its origins in the domestication and possession of animals by other animals, and therefore it has a symbolic way of making us forget our own animal nature.
WTF? Seriously? How does one follow from the other?
May as well say that “masturbation” has its origin in the opposable thumb, and therefore it has a “symbolic way” of distinguishing us from our chimpanzee cousins. (Yes, I know chimpanzees have opposable thumbs.)
This isn’t philosophy, it’s a kind of gematria. It’s essentially a kind of word association game, but instead of thinking that the association reveals something about the philosopher’s subconscious, he thinks it somehow necessarily true about the real world.
If we go backward in time, we find that for our remote ancestors placing an animal on an altar is akin to burning money.
Which reveals that money as atonement is not “blasphemous”, as you later declare. The whole point of the sacrifice as a means of atonement is that the penitent must lose something of value—presumably of value comparable to the transgression. Whether that means sacrificing a goat (and subsequently buying a replacement goat) or sacrificing the monetary value of a goat is irrelevant.
Money ultimately endangers religion.
I’ll buy that. (Pun not actually intended, but certainly welcome.)
The amount of money one has is directly related to the degree to which one can free oneself from the hardships of primitive life—easy access to food, shelter, clean water, art, beauty, and so on. People who have that no longer need (or want) religion. That’s why religious belief has declined so rapidly in most wealthy western democracies.
So, yes—money endangers religion. But don’t say it like it’s a bad thing.
Because it is the lowest common denominator for motives it ultimately and symbolically challenges God, the highest common denominator for motives.
I’m afraid you’ve got that backwards. Being motivated by real-world values is certainly a higher motive than superstitious dread.
RE: Yep. Wanking, all right. by Anonymous :: NR0 :: Show
Hebrew online Gematria calculator: http://www.c2kb.com/gematria. מחשבון גימטריה עברית.