0 Nerd-Its - +

RE: Jackson

Comment a comment by Jackson, published on 27 October 2009
Navigate to the top level to view all replies to the poll Best American General?
Navigate up one level to see this comment's parent.
other nerds have left 4 comments below

Perhaps. you have a point with Andrew Jackson. But I wonder if Stonewall could really be considered an American general at all. He was a Confederate general. Did the Confederacy consider themselves American or Confederates or both? Whether they did or not doesn’t matter as I assume this poll is asking “Best U.S. General” in the current vernacular. Just a random thought. Anyone feel free to jump in with corrections to everything I just said.

Thread parent sort order:
Thread verbosity:
0 Nerd-Its - +
RE: Jackson by Occams :: NR8

I like Andy because he beat several very experienced British generals, who had battle hardened European professional soldiers, marines, and artillery, in a major battle with lots of clever tactical manoevering.

He was an old man at the time, called out of retirement to lead a rabble amateurish force. Bringing them up to speed in a very short time under the pressure of an invasion would have required a great deal of leadership. He was lucky to have the terrain on his side as well as the fact that the raiders had very limited objectives. Even so, the consequences of defeat would have been enormous and may have even led to the loss of the Louisiana territory and a second revoloutionary war.

0 Nerd-Its - +
RE: Jackson by Anonymous :: NR0

STONEWALL Jackson was the ""greatest"" general the New World has produced, as his Valley Campaign reveals. He was a Virginian first & foremost, and a Southerner secondly, as we all understand ourselves down here under the Occupation. someone asked of STONEWALL’s politics, and the chapter in R.L. Dabney’s Life & Campaigns of the Presbyterian Soldier par excellance is to be found here, he was a thorough Secessionist when the Time came:

http://www.dabneyarchive.com/Life%20and%20Campaigns%20of%20Thos.%20J%20Jackson/Chapter%205%20-%20Secession.pdf

[note the .pdf file is large, but the price is Right!!!]

…—-John Wilkes Booth

The Showcase

Nerd-Its   Nerd Trends   Last Ten  

  1. RE: Please read the Book of Mormon! // Jake is way off base in God before Country in the Military
  2. RE: nerdy? in God before Country in the Military
  3. RE: Now it's, "Please watch Expelled"? in God before Country in the Military
  4. RE: Nursing Question in Nurse Does "Right Thing", Goes To Jail
  5. RE: nerdy? in God before Country in the Military
  6. Nursing Question in Nurse Does "Right Thing", Goes To Jail
  7. RE: nerdy? in God before Country in the Military
  8. RE: Please read the Book of Mormon! // Jake is way off base in God before Country in the Military
  9. RE: Discussing Book of Mormon anachronisms in God before Country in the Military
  10. RE: Discussing Book of Mormon anachronisms in God before Country in the Military

What is OmniNerd?

Omninerd_icon Welcome! OmniNerd's content is generated by nerds like you. Learn more.

Voting Booth

Legalizing medical marijuana?

28 votes, 1 comment