a
comment
by scottb,
published on 23 December 2008
Navigate to the top level
to view all replies to the poll I'm a?
Navigate up one level
to see this comment's parent.
a lone nerd has left 1 comment below
Device support is a big problem with Linux, but it’s wrong to blame Linux. (Before you start – I know you didn’t actually blame Linux, but many people do, and I’m addressing them, not you.)
Linux does have pretty good device support – most common hardware works well. But there’s a lot of stuff that just doesn’t have good support.
The real blame goes to the manufacturers, though. I do understand that they’re unwilling to take on the cost of supporting another OS that doesn’t have deep market penetration, but that shouldn’t preclude them from giving out enough information to allow open source developers to build drivers.
There’s a difference between support – which requires at least the attempt at well-written documentation, staff to answer questions, and usually some advertising and marketing efforts – and technical openness. Having one guy on staff who’s willing to answer questions in his off time would usually be enough – there are open-source drivers that have been built with far less than that.
Instead, companies treat their interfaces as if they’re state secrets. I’ve never understood the logic — the Linux market may not be huge, but it’s also not tiny. There are millions of us out here.
Instead, companies treat their interfaces as if they’re state secrets.
This is further convoluted by the fact that many companies (HP) use third party software houses for many of their drivers, so there may actually be no internal support.
Then, like in the case of the wireless USB dongle I first complained about — it was a D-Link brand with a Marvel chip inside (and probably a third party driver after that.. who knows?) A different D-LInk Revision level on the same product might use an Atheros wireless chip. The craziness lives on.
RE: Back to Windows by gnifyus :: NR6 :: Show
Instead, companies treat their interfaces as if they’re state secrets.
This is further convoluted by the fact that many companies (HP) use third party software houses for many of their drivers, so there may actually be no internal support.
Then, like in the case of the wireless USB dongle I first complained about — it was a D-Link brand with a Marvel chip inside (and probably a third party driver after that.. who knows?) A different D-LInk Revision level on the same product might use an Atheros wireless chip. The craziness lives on.