3 Nerd-Its - +

Logic..

Comment a comment by Dwayne Sudduth (ldsudduth), published on 21 August 2008
Navigate to the top level to view all replies to the article College Presidents Call for Lower Drinking Age
other nerds have left 7 comments below

The reasoning for the assignment of the age of 21 has almost legendary roots, but the real reason is simply this: A person’s brain does not stop developing until his or her early to mid-20s. Over consumption of alcohol while the brain is still developing can lead to long-lasting deficits in cognitive abilities, including learning and memory.

Here are some interesting facts from the CDC website:

  • 11% of alcohol is consumed by ages 12-20; 90% of which is consumed in Binge Drinking.
  • 45% drank some amount of alcohol.
  • 26% binge drank.
  • 11% drove after drinking alcohol.
  • 29% rode with a driver who had been drinking alcohol.
  • In 2005, there were more than 145,000 emergency rooms visits by youth 12 to 20 years for injuries and other conditions linked to alcohol.

It is a fact that many rights and privileges all have different ages of initiation. For Example, You can get a hunting license at age 12 (but can hunt before then), a fishing license at age 16 (some states have Jr. Licenses—but no license is required until those ages are met), I can drive at 16 with a full license but with someone else as a supervisor as young a 15 in some states. I must be 25 to serve in the U.S. House of Representatives , but for U.S. President, I must be 35. Other regulated rights include the sale and use of tobacco, and legal consent for sexual intercourse in states where prostitution is legal. Vendors, such as car rental facilities and hotels, also have set the minimum age for a person to use their services—25-years-old to rent a car and 21-years-old to rent a hotel room.

However, this said, I am still a supporter of a Drinking Age of 18. Why, you might ask? Several reasons.

  1. I learned at a very early age about responsibilities associated with various things—guns, alcohol, driving, etc. Consequently, I’ve made my choices based on that instruction. While I will admit to more than one instance of drinking FAR too much—I also have never driven after consuming more than 2 drinks—EVER. Unlike the socio/psycho pundits out there, I do believe that you can instruct your children on responsibility and they will learn from it.
  2. People are no more responsible at 21 than they are at 18, if they haven’t been instructed in responsibility. It’s not something that appears magically at a certain age like puberty.
  3. The Brain Development argument doesn’t hold water if drinking is done in moderation. Aren’t we complaining now about overweight kids? In perspective, this is far more frightening to me.
  4. At 18, I am allowed to marry, take out most kinds of loans (not sure about mortgages), or serve in the military without Parental Consent.
  5. My biggest reason—and one that arguably carries MORE responsibility with it: I can VOTE at 18.
  • Thread parent sort order:
    Thread verbosity:
    3 Nerd-Its - +
    RE: Logic.. by EyeOfSage :: NR6
    Well, I have to disagree on two things here. First, about 3 years ago, I read on a psychology magazine article that a person’s brain does not stop developing until the age of 50. Meaning an adult brain is not fully matured until age of 50 is reached. Second, people do change in a course of years. And 3-4 years is a long time. Students will change, especially in such a complex environment such as college. I personally witness numerous friends who use to drink so much in their freshmen year that the bathroom is flooded with vomit everyday. Then during their 2nd year, they just suddenly became more mature and drank less and in moderation. I was shocked. I thought I accidentally stepped into a rupture in space-time fabric and got send into a different reality or something. I asked them why, and here’s their response averagely: "I don’t know, I just feel it’s not that fun and exciting anymore. I’m kind of sick of it anyway. I have more important stuff to do now" Other than that, I agree with the rest of your comments.

    The Showcase

    Nerd-Its   Nerd Trends   Last Ten  

    1. RE: Why wouldn't it be a religion? Yes, but .... in Scientology: We've had it with you
    2. RE: Why wouldn't it be a religion? Yes, but .... in Scientology: We've had it with you
    3. RE: Why wouldn't it be a religion? Yes, but .... in Scientology: We've had it with you
    4. Sick care in U.S. Healthcare: the Best, the Worst, and the Irrelevant
    5. RE: Busy guy in Catholic Exorcist Points Finger at Vatican
    6. RE: The true solution in Scientology: We've had it with you
    7. Manic Fits in Scientology: We've had it with you
    8. RE: Busy guy in Catholic Exorcist Points Finger at Vatican
    9. RE: Why wouldn't it be a religion? Yes, but .... in Scientology: We've had it with you
    10. RE: cell phones in How To Beat Traffic Mathematically

    What is OmniNerd?

    Omninerd_icon Welcome! OmniNerd's content is generated by nerds like you. Learn more.

    Voting Booth

    The Interstate Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution empowers Congress to regulate?

    9 votes, 0 comments