Add a Comment
Email This
Statistics
Thread parent sort order:
Thread verbosity:
1 Nerd-It
RE: Context over predictive value
The point is what causes the astrologer to issue the "spiritual storm warning". If he's just making stuff up, it's not useful. If he gives the same warning to everyone, it's not useful. If he's giving helpful advice, by say knowing the person in question well, and seeing the psychological stormclouds on the horizon, that is fine. But it's called psychology. Leave the stars nonsense out of it.
This comment has 1 reply.
RSS
Context over predictive value
There will always be something like astrology around. It may even provide a useful function in giving people a context or framework for understanding their experiences, even if it isn't necessarily accurate in a historical sense. The thing even an experienced astrologer will tell you is that astrology predicts trends and forces, not specific events. It's like a spiritual weather report--the astrologer can issue a storm warning, but can't say for sure if your house will be demolished by a passing tornado, or if the storm will pass you by altogether.
If it helps people get some context for understanding and overcoming the challenges in their lives, it's a good and healthy thing. If it becomes an obsession or crutch, and the person can't do anything without consulting their horoscope, well, then it's time to put it aside.
View Full Discussion