Loading 3 Votes - +

Do Those Who Serve Represent America


It wasn’t too long ago that Defense Secretary Robert Gates delivered a speech (transcript) to Duke University students focusing on a call to service. While praising ROTC students, Gates alluded to what seemed to be an increasingly small population of people serving their country, “We’ve had so few fighting our wars for so long. How long can these brave and broad young shoulders bear the burden that we as a military, a government and a society continue to place on them?” In a nutshell, military service is something for other people to do. One of the problems is that as a volunteer military, servicemembers are becoming a niche segment of the population rather than drawing equally across the nation. Some fear that means the armed forces may slowly become less and less in touch with those they are defending.

On the other hand, in this recent round of elections there were twenty-seven candidates who had served in either Afghanistan or Iraq. Veteran candidates bring a unique skillset to the political arena along with firsthand experience to the failures of diplomacy. Some may argue the previous points; that aside from über-patriotism, veterans are not entirely touch with the American people. Is a cast of veterans the best line of defense against future conflict while cutting through general political B.S. or will they quickly be cast aside by seasoned political wranglers?

Similarly tagged OmniNerd content:

Thread parent sort order:
Thread verbosity:
0 Votes  - +
Of course the do. by Occams

I think that technically the answer to that question is: Yes they do.
The percentage of people who volunteer to serve in the US forces represents the percentage of people in America today who are patriotic enough to volunteer to serve in the US forces.

There is a probably much higher percentage who talk patriotically, but avoid joining the military. You would not expect them to be represented in that first number.

There are those who are happy to allow volunteers to do their fighting for them.

Then there are those who are happy to let conscripts do their fighting for them.
There are those who believe that if it is important enough they will be conscripted, and they prefer to wait for that to happen.
I think that all these positions are quite defensible rationally and morally.
It takes all kinds. If the question is really about whether the volunteers are typical of most Americans, I don’t understand why that would be so.

Share & Socialize

What is OmniNerd?

Omninerd_icon Welcome! OmniNerd's content is generated by nerds like you. Learn more.

Voting Booth

Can Trump make America great again?

14 votes, 1 comment